To top it all off, Mercy is having difficulty coping with life without her twin sister Rebekah, who has just started college in the city. Mercy visits Rebekah and tries to forget Samuel by mingling with cute Englischers, but it's no use—she just can't get over him.
Mercy figures out a way that Rebekah can help her to get Samuel back, just in time for the Valentine's Day sled-riding party. Everything will be wunderbar—if only the girls can get Samuel to cooperate!
Will Mercy's plan work? Will Samuel be her Amish Valentine this year?